When it comes to avalanche safety, having a reliable and efficient snow probe is crucial for quickly locating and extracting buried individuals. Two popular options in the market are the BCA Stealth 300 Carbon Avalanche Probe and the Ortovox Steel 320+ PFA Probe. In this comparison, we'll delve into the features, benefits, and differences between these two high-quality snow probes.
Material and Construction
The BCA Stealth 300 Carbon Avalanche Probe is made from carbon fiber, which provides exceptional strength-to-weight ratio, making it an ideal choice for backcountry enthusiasts who prioritize lightweight gear. The probe's carbon construction also allows for a more compact design, making it easier to carry in a backpack or attach to a harness.
On the other hand, the Ortovox Steel 320+ PFA Probe is constructed from high-strength steel, which offers unparalleled durability and resistance to bending or breaking. While steel probes are generally heavier than their carbon counterparts, the Ortovox Steel 320+ PFA Probe's robust design ensures that it can withstand the rigors of frequent use and harsh environments.
Length and Deployment
Both snow probes offer impressive length ranges, with the BCA Stealth 300 Carbon Avalanche Probe extending up to 300cm (118in) and the Ortovox Steel 320+ PFA Probe reaching a maximum length of 320cm (126in). The Ortovox probe has a slight edge in terms of reach, which can be beneficial in deeper snowpacks or when searching for victims in complex terrain.
In terms of deployment, both probes feature quick-locking mechanisms that allow for fast and easy assembly. However, the BCA Stealth 300 Carbon Avalanche Probe's Speed Ferrule system is particularly noteworthy, as it enables users to rapidly deploy the probe with a simple twist-and-click motion.
Probe Tip and Sensitivity
The probe tip is a critical component of any snow probe, as it directly affects the user's ability to detect subtle changes in resistance and pinpoint the location of a buried individual. The Ortovox Steel 320+ PFA Probe features a specially designed PFA (Probe Ferrule Assembly) system, which includes a reinforced probe tip that provides exceptional sensitivity and accuracy.
The BCA Stealth 300 Carbon Avalanche Probe also boasts a highly sensitive probe tip, which is designed to detect even the slightest changes in snow density. While both probes offer excellent sensitivity, the Ortovox Steel 320+ PFA Probe's PFA system may provide a slight advantage in terms of detecting subtle variations in snowpack.
Weight and Packability
As mentioned earlier, the BCA Stealth 300 Carbon Avalanche Probe is significantly lighter than the Ortovox Steel 320+ PFA Probe, weighing in at approximately 340g (12oz) compared to the Ortovox probe's 560g (19.7oz). This weight difference can be a significant factor for backcountry travelers who prioritize lightweight gear and efficient packing.
In terms of packability, both snow probes are designed to be compact and easy to stow away in a backpack or harness. However, the BCA Stealth 300 Carbon Avalanche Probe's smaller diameter and more compact design make it easier to fit into tight spaces and reduce bulk in a user's pack.
Conclusion
Ultimately, the choice between the BCA Stealth 300 Carbon Avalanche Probe and the Ortovox Steel 320+ PFA Probe will depend on individual preferences and priorities. If you're looking for a lightweight, compact snow probe with exceptional strength-to-weight ratio, the BCA Stealth 300 Carbon Avalanche Probe may be the better option.
On the other hand, if you prioritize durability, sensitivity, and reach, the Ortovox Steel 320+ PFA Probe is an excellent choice. Its robust steel construction, reinforced probe tip, and impressive length range make it an ideal snow probe for serious backcountry enthusiasts and avalanche professionals.
Regardless of which snow probe you choose, it's essential to remember that these tools are only effective when used in conjunction with proper training, experience, and caution. By selecting a high-quality snow probe like the BCA Stealth 300 Carbon Avalanche Probe or the Ortovox Steel 320+ PFA Probe, you'll be better equipped to respond quickly and effectively in emergency situations, and stay safe in the backcountry.
