Products are chosen independently by our editors. Purchases made through our links may earn us a commission.

Best Ice Cube Trays

Updated
An expert product reviewer known for her comprehensive analysis and in-depth expertise across various categories, providing unbiased and insightful reviews.
Updated

Main Features

  • Flexible silicone material
  • Steel-reinforced rim
  • Dishwasher safe
  • 15 large ice cubes

Product Overview

The Silicone Easy-Release Tray by Tovolo is perfect for those who want to simplify their ice-making routine. Made from high-quality, food-grade silicone, this tray is flexible yet durable, allowing you to pop out ice cubes effortlessly.

The tray holds 15 cubes, which are large enough to cool your drink quickly without watering it down too fast.The silicone material is not only durable but also safe for freezing and dishwasher use, making cleanup a breeze.

The tray also features a steel-reinforced rim, adding stability when filling and transporting to the freezer. Whether you're hosting a party or just enjoying a cold beverage at home, this tray is a reliable and user-friendly option.

PROS
  • Easy to release cubes
  • Durable and flexible
  • Dishwasher safe
CONS
  • Takes up more freezer space
  • Higher price point

Product Specifications

  • Material Food-grade silicone
  • Capacity 15 cubes
Best Price / Quality
OXO Good Grips Ice Cube Tray

Main Features

  • Stackable with lids
  • BPA-free plastic
  • Non-slip design
  • 14 standard-size cubes per tray

Product Overview

The Stackable Ice Cube Tray by OXO is designed to maximize space and efficiency in your freezer. Each tray comes with its own lid, allowing you to stack them without worrying about the trays sticking to each other.

This also helps to keep your ice cubes free from unwanted freezer odors.The trays are made from BPA-free plastic, ensuring your ice is safe for consumption. Each tray creates 14 cubes, which are a standard size to fit in most drinkware.

The non-slip design makes it easy to carry the trays even when they are full of water. Cleanup is straightforward as these trays are dishwasher safe.

PROS
  • Space-saving design
  • Keeps ice cubes odor-free
  • Dishwasher safe
CONS
  • Plastic may crack over time
  • Lids can be hard to secure

Product Specifications

  • Material BPA-free plastic
  • Capacity 14 cubes per tray

Main Features

  • Produces giant cubes
  • Flexible silicone
  • Dishwasher safe
  • 8 large cubes

Product Overview

The Giant Ice Cube Tray by Vremi is ideal for those who prefer a larger ice cube to keep their beverages cold for an extended period. Each tray produces 8 extra-large cubes, which are perfect for whiskey, cocktails, or any other drink where you don't want the ice to melt quickly.

Made from flexible silicone, the tray allows for easy removal of the cubes. It is also dishwasher safe, making cleanup a breeze. The tray’s large size means you can fill it with water, juice, or even coffee to create unique drink experiences.

The durable design ensures long-lasting use.

PROS
  • Keeps drinks cooler longer
  • Easy to release
  • Dishwasher safe
CONS
  • Takes longer to freeze
  • Occupies more freezer space

Product Specifications

  • Material Silicone
  • Capacity 8 cubes

Main Features

  • Creates round ice spheres
  • Durable silicone
  • Fill line indicator
  • Tight-sealing lid

Product Overview

The Sphere Ice Mold by Tovolo is designed for those who want to add a touch of elegance to their drinks. Each mold creates a 2.5-inch ice sphere, which is not only visually appealing but also melts slower than traditional ice cubes.

This makes it perfect for high-end cocktails and whiskey.The mold is made from durable silicone and has a fill line indicator, ensuring you get a perfect sphere every time. It also features a tight-sealing lid to prevent spills and freezer odors from affecting your ice.

The mold is dishwasher safe, making it easy to clean and reuse.

PROS
  • Visually appealing
  • Melts slower
  • Easy to use
CONS
  • Takes longer to freeze
  • Limited to one sphere per mold

Product Specifications

  • Material Silicone
  • Capacity 2.5-inch sphere

Main Features

  • Produces mini cubes
  • Flexible silicone
  • BPA-free
  • 160 cubes per tray

Product Overview

The Mini Ice Cube Tray by Kitch is perfect for those who need smaller ice cubes for their drinks or smoothies. Each tray produces 160 mini cubes, allowing for quick cooling and easy blending. The smaller size also makes it easier to fit multiple trays in your freezer.

Made from flexible, BPA-free silicone, the tray allows for easy removal of the tiny cubes. It is also dishwasher safe, making it convenient to clean. The tray’s compact design ensures it fits easily in any freezer, and the mini cubes are great for adding to water bottles or other small containers.

PROS
  • Quick cooling
  • Easy to remove cubes
  • Dishwasher safe
CONS
  • Cubes melt quickly
  • Can be harder to fill

Product Specifications

  • Material Silicone
  • Capacity 160 cubes per tray

Types of Ice Cube Trays

Plastic Ice Cube Trays:Plastic trays are the most common and affordable option. They are lightweight, often come in multi-packs, and can produce a large number of ice cubes at once. However, they can sometimes be difficult to twist and turn, making it harder to release the ice cubes.

Silicone Ice Cube Trays:Silicone trays have gained popularity due to their flexibility. They make ice cube removal easier since you can simply push the cubes out from the bottom. Silicone trays are also durable and can be used for other purposes, like freezing baby food or making chocolate molds. However, they can be more expensive than plastic trays and sometimes absorb freezer odors if not properly maintained.

Stainless Steel Ice Cube Trays:Stainless steel trays are a durable and eco-friendly option. They are resistant to cracking and can last for many years. These trays often come with a release lever, making it easier to get the ice cubes out. On the downside, they are usually more expensive and can be heavier, which might be a consideration if you have limited freezer space.

Novelty Ice Cube Trays:These trays come in various shapes and sizes, such as spheres, stars, or even movie-themed designs. They can add a fun element to your drinks, making them a hit at parties. However, they may not be practical for everyday use due to their often smaller capacity and more complex shapes, which can take longer to freeze.

Factors to Consider

Ease of Use:Look for trays that are easy to fill and easy to empty. Silicone trays are often easier to handle in this regard, but some plastic trays come with features like a quick-release mechanism that can also be very convenient.

Size of Ice Cubes:Consider what you will be using the ice cubes for. Larger cubes melt more slowly, making them ideal for cocktails, while smaller cubes are perfect for quickly cooling down a glass of water or a soft drink.

Capacity:Think about how many ice cubes you need at a time. If you often entertain guests or have a large family, a tray that makes more cubes at once would be beneficial. For smaller households, a single or double tray might suffice.

Material Quality:Ensure that the tray is made from high-quality, food-grade materials. This is especially important for plastic trays, as lower-quality plastics can crack over time or absorb odors from your freezer. Silicone trays should be BPA-free and dishwasher safe for easy cleaning.

Design and Aesthetics:While functionality is key, the design can also play a role in your decision. Some trays come with lids to prevent spillage and keep the ice cubes from absorbing freezer odors. Others have stackable designs to save space. Choose a tray that fits your personal style and kitchen decor.

Maintenance and Care

Proper maintenance can extend the life of your ice cube tray. Silicone and plastic trays can generally be cleaned in the dishwasher, but it's a good idea to check the manufacturer's instructions. Stainless steel trays should be hand-washed to maintain their finish. To prevent odors, consider storing the trays in a tightly sealed freezer bag when not in use.

Conclusion

Choosing the right ice cube tray involves considering various factors like material, ease of use, capacity, and design. Whether you opt for the flexibility of silicone, the durability of stainless steel, or the affordability of plastic, the ideal tray should meet your specific needs and preferences. By taking the time to evaluate these aspects, you can ensure that you always have the perfect ice cubes ready for any occasion.