Search Results
Products are chosen independently by our editors. Purchases made through our links may earn us a commission.

BEST PAINT TRAYS OF 2026

Updated
Updated
BEST OF THE BEST
Pro Grade PGPT01
Pro Grade
PGPT01
Durable & Leak-Proof
The Pro Grade Paint Tray Set is a durable and reliable option for a variety of painting tasks. It includes a tray, liners, and roller covers, making it convenient for both small touch-ups and large projects.
Check Price
Check price at Amazon
Pros & Cons
PROS
  • Durable construction
  • Comes with multiple liners
  • Smooth and even finish
  • Easy cleanup
CONS
  • Limited to 9-inch rollers
  • Plastic may stain with certain paints
BEST BANG FOR THE BUCK
Wooster Brush R404-11
Wooster Brush
R404-11
Eco-Friendly & Reusable
Plastic Tray is an eco-friendly paint tray option that is both durable and reusable. Ideal for homeowners and professionals alike, it offers a reliable solution for various painting tasks.
Check Price
Check price at Amazon
Pros & Cons
PROS
  • Eco-friendly
  • Durable
  • Generous paint capacity
  • Ensures even roller loading
CONS
  • May not fit all roller sizes
  • Slightly heavier than plastic alternatives
BEST OF THE BEST
Pro Grade PGPT01
Durable & Leak-Proof
Material: Plastic
Number of Liners: 5
Roller Size: 9 inches

The Pro Grade Paint Tray Set is designed to meet the needs of both professional painters and DIY enthusiasts. The tray is made of high-quality plastic that is resistant to cracking and leaking. The set includes multiple liners, which makes cleanup a breeze and allows for quick color changes.

The included roller covers are designed to provide a smooth and even finish, reducing the need for multiple coats. This set is perfect for anyone looking to complete a painting project efficiently and effectively.

PROS
  • Durable construction
  • Comes with multiple liners
  • Smooth and even finish
  • Easy cleanup
CONS
  • Limited to 9-inch rollers
  • Plastic may stain with certain paints
BEST BANG FOR THE BUCK
Wooster Brush R404-11
Eco-Friendly & Reusable
Material: Recycled Plastic
Well Depth: 2 inches
Roller Size: 11 inches

The Wooster Brush R404-11 Plastic Tray is crafted from high-quality recycled materials, making it a sustainable choice for environmentally conscious painters. Its robust construction ensures that it can withstand multiple uses without showing signs of wear.

The tray's deep well holds a generous amount of paint, reducing the need for frequent refills. Its textured grid pattern assists in evenly loading the roller, ensuring a smooth application every time.

Ideal for both large projects and small touch-ups, this tray is a practical addition to any painter's toolkit.

PROS
  • Eco-friendly
  • Durable
  • Generous paint capacity
  • Ensures even roller loading
CONS
  • May not fit all roller sizes
  • Slightly heavier than plastic alternatives
Handy Paint Products HPT01
Compact & Convenient
Material: Plastic
Capacity: 1 quart
Roller Size: 6 inches

The Handy Paint Tray is designed for those quick touch-ups and small projects that don't require a large tray. Its compact size makes it easy to carry and maneuver, even in tight spaces. The tray features a comfortable handle and a built-in grid pattern to help evenly distribute paint on the roller.

Made from durable plastic, it can be reused multiple times and is easy to clean. This tray is perfect for homeowners who need a reliable solution for small painting tasks.

PROS
  • Easy to handle
  • Ideal for small projects
  • Durable construction
  • Ergonomic design
CONS
  • Limited paint capacity
  • Not suitable for large projects
BERCOM HANDy
Heavy-Duty & Large
Material: Heavy-Duty Plastic
Well Depth: 3 inches
Roller Size: 12 inches

The BERCOM Handy Paint Tray is built to handle the demands of large-scale painting projects. Made from heavy-duty plastic, it is resistant to cracking and can hold a significant amount of paint. The tray features a deep well and a textured grid to help evenly load the roller.

Its large size reduces the need for frequent refills, making it more efficient for big jobs. The tray is also easy to clean, allowing for multiple uses. This product is perfect for professional painters who need a reliable and durable paint tray.

PROS
  • Durable
  • Large capacity
  • Efficient for big projects
  • Even roller loading
CONS
  • Bulky
  • Higher cost
Bates BPT01
Budget-Friendly & Practical
Material: Plastic
Number of Liners: 4
Roller Size: 9 inches

The Bates Paint Tray Set is an affordable option that comes with all the essentials for a painting project. The set includes a sturdy plastic tray, multiple liners, and roller covers. The tray is designed to be durable and easy to clean, while the liners make it easy to switch between different colors without having to wash the tray each time.

The roller covers are designed to provide a smooth finish, ensuring that your paint job looks professional. This set is ideal for homeowners and DIY enthusiasts looking for a cost-effective solution.

PROS
  • Great value for money
  • Comes with all essentials
  • Easy to clean
  • Smooth finish
CONS
  • Basic design
  • Limited to 9-inch rollers

How our picks compare

SpecificationPro Grade PGPT01Wooster Brush R404-11Handy Paint Products HPT01BERCOM HANDyBates BPT01
MaterialPlasticRecycled PlasticPlasticHeavy-Duty PlasticPlastic
Number of Liners5---4
Roller Size9 inches11 inches6 inches12 inches9 inches
Well Depth-2 inches-3 inches-
Capacity--1 quart--

Material Considerations

Paint trays come in various materials including plastic, metal, and disposable options. Each material has its own set of advantages and disadvantages.

Plastic Trays:Plastic paint trays are the most common. They are lightweight, easy to clean, and usually quite durable. However, their durability can vary depending on the quality of the plastic. Higher-end plastic trays are often made from thicker, more resilient materials that resist cracking and breaking.

Metal Trays:Metal trays, often made of aluminum, are highly durable and can withstand repeated use. They are easy to clean, which saves time during and after painting projects. However, they can be heavier and may rust if not properly dried and stored.

Disposable Trays:Disposable paint trays are convenient for quick projects or when working with multiple colors. They eliminate the need for cleaning, which can save time. However, they are less environmentally friendly and can add to the overall cost if used frequently.

Size and Depth

The size of the paint tray should correspond to the size of your paint roller and the scope of your project. Standard trays typically measure around 9 inches wide, which is suitable for most rollers. Larger trays can accommodate wider rollers, which are useful for covering large surfaces quickly.

Depth is another critical factor. Deeper trays can hold more paint, which reduces the need for frequent refilling. This is particularly beneficial for larger projects where efficiency is key. However, deeper trays can also be heavier when filled, which might be a consideration if you need to move them frequently.

Design Features

Ridges and Wells:Most paint trays feature ridges or wells that help distribute paint evenly on the roller. These ridges are crucial for preventing excess paint, which can cause drips and uneven application. Look for trays with well-designed ridges that efficiently spread the paint across the roller.

Spout:Some trays come with a spout for easy pouring of unused paint back into the can. This feature can minimize waste and make the cleanup process simpler.

Handles and Grip:A good paint tray should have a comfortable grip or handle, making it easy to carry, especially when it’s filled with paint. Ergonomic designs can reduce strain and make the tray easier to maneuver.

Liner Compatibility

Using tray liners can make cleanup significantly easier. Check if the paint tray you’re considering is compatible with liners. Liners are often made of thin plastic and can be disposed of after use, saving you the hassle of cleaning the tray itself. Ensure that the liners fit snugly and don’t slip around during use.

Stability

Stability is crucial to prevent spills and accidents. Look for trays with a wide base and a sturdy construction that won’t tip over easily. Some trays come with non-slip features or rubberized feet, which can provide additional stability on different surfaces.

Price and Brand

Price can be an indicator of quality, but it’s not always the case. Higher-priced trays are often made from more durable materials and have better design features. However, there are plenty of affordable options that perform well for occasional use. Consider well-known brands that have positive reviews and a good reputation in the market.

Eco-Friendly Options

For those concerned about environmental impact, look for paint trays made from recycled materials or those that can be recycled after use. Some companies offer eco-friendly products that do not compromise on quality or functionality.

Conclusion

Choosing the best paint tray involves considering factors such as material, size, design features, liner compatibility, stability, price, and brand reputation. By carefully evaluating these aspects, you can find a paint tray that meets your needs and enhances your painting experience. Whether you’re a professional painter or a DIY enthusiast, the right tray can make a substantial difference in your project’s outcome.