When it comes to protecting one's head while engaging in rock climbing, skiing, or other adventure sports, climbing helmets are a crucial piece of equipment. Two popular options in this category are the Black Diamond Half Dome and the Grivel Stealth. In this comparison, we'll delve into the features, design, and performance of these two helmets to help you decide which one best suits your needs.
Design and Construction
The Black Diamond Half Dome is a classic climbing helmet that has been around for decades. Its design is characterized by a durable ABS shell with a foam liner, providing excellent protection against impact. The helmet's shape is more rounded, offering comprehensive coverage of the head, including the back and sides. The Half Dome features a simple yet effective adjustment system, allowing for a secure fit on various head sizes.
On the other hand, the Grivel Stealth boasts a more modern and sleek design. Its shell is made from a lightweight and breathable polycarbonate material, which provides excellent impact resistance while keeping the helmet's weight to a minimum. The Stealth features a more aerodynamic shape, with a narrower profile that reduces wind resistance and makes it easier to wear under hoods or with glasses. Grivel's proprietary "Air-Fit" system allows for easy adjustments and ensures a snug fit.
Weight and Comfort
The Black Diamond Half Dome weighs in at approximately 340 grams (12 oz), which is relatively standard for climbing helmets. While not the lightest option, its weight is well-distributed, making it comfortable to wear for extended periods.
In contrast, the Grivel Stealth tips the scales at a mere 220 grams (7.8 oz), making it one of the lightest climbing helmets on the market. This significant weight reduction is achieved through the use of advanced materials and a more minimalist design. The Stealth's comfort is further enhanced by its ventilated design, which promotes airflow and helps to keep the head cool during intense activities.
Safety Features
Both helmets meet or exceed the relevant safety standards for climbing helmets, including CE EN 12492 and UIAA 106. However, the Grivel Stealth has an added feature: a built-in "Anti-Twist" system that prevents the helmet from rotating on impact, providing enhanced protection against rotational forces.
The Black Diamond Half Dome, while not featuring the same level of advanced safety technology, still offers excellent protection due to its robust design and well-distributed weight. Its simplicity also makes it less prone to mechanical failure or component malfunction.
Additional Features
The Grivel Stealth features a built-in headlamp clip, allowing users to easily attach their light sources for nighttime climbing or skiing excursions. The helmet's sleek design also accommodates goggles or other accessories with ease.
In contrast, the Black Diamond Half Dome has a more traditional design and doesn't feature any specific accessory attachments. However, its simple shape makes it compatible with most headlamps and goggles on the market.
Conclusion
When choosing between the Black Diamond Half Dome and the Grivel Stealth, consider your specific needs and priorities. If you value simplicity, durability, and comprehensive coverage, the Half Dome is an excellent choice. Its classic design has been trusted by climbers for decades, and its robust construction ensures long-lasting protection.
On the other hand, if you prioritize lightweight comfort, advanced safety features, and a sleek design, the Grivel Stealth is the better option. Its innovative Air-Fit system, Anti-Twist technology, and built-in headlamp clip make it an excellent choice for climbers who demand the latest in helmet technology.
Ultimately, both helmets are high-quality climbing helmets that provide excellent protection for your most valuable asset: your head. Whether you choose the Black Diamond Half Dome or the Grivel Stealth, rest assured that you'll be well-protected on your next adventure.
